|Year : 2013 | Volume
| Issue : 5 | Page : 40-44
Elementary school enrolment and its determinants among children with cerebral palsy in Thiruvananthapuram district, Kerala, India
Thekkumkara Surendran Nair Anish, Reshmi Ramachandran, P Sivaram, Seetha Mohandas, Archana Sasidharan, Pallipurathu Reghunathan Nair Sreelakshmi
Department of Community Medicine, Government Medical College, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, India
|Date of Web Publication||14-Aug-2013|
Thekkumkara Surendran Nair Anish
Department of Community Medicine, Government Medical College, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala - 695 011
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Context: There is enough documented evidence to prove the benefits of early and appropriate initiation of education among children with cerebral palsy (CP). Aim: To find out the proportion of children with CP who are enrolled for some kind of formal education and to study the determinants of the same. Setting and Design: This cross sectional study was done among children, attending the special clinics at government medical college, Thiruvananthapuram. Materials and Methods: Children between 3 and 12 years of age diagnosed with CP were subjects for the study. Statistical Analysis Used: Enrollment for any form of formal education was the major outcome variable. The factors associated with initiation of formal education were tested using Chi-square test or Fischer's exact test. Independent association of each factor was evaluated through binary logistic Regression analysis. Results and Conclusions: The mean (SD) age of the children (n = 86) was 5.7 (2.3) years with forty-six (53.5%) of them being girls. Diplegia was the commonest limb abnormality found. Fifty-two (60.5%) children were undergoing some kind of schooling. Those children who were less dependent physically and those who had achieved better language development were regular school goers. After binary logistic regression the ability of a child to speak in sentences (P = 0.008) and ambulatory level of the child (P = 0.019) were factors which favored, whereas delay in attaining the adaptive developmental milestone of transferring objects from one hand to another (P = 0.014) was found to be detrimental for school enrollment.
Keywords: Cerebral Palsy, cerebral palsy and school enrollment, education and disability
|How to cite this article:|
Anish TS, Ramachandran R, Sivaram P, Mohandas S, Sasidharan A, Sreelakshmi PR. Elementary school enrolment and its determinants among children with cerebral palsy in Thiruvananthapuram district, Kerala, India. J Neurosci Rural Pract 2013;4, Suppl S1:40-4
|How to cite this URL:|
Anish TS, Ramachandran R, Sivaram P, Mohandas S, Sasidharan A, Sreelakshmi PR. Elementary school enrolment and its determinants among children with cerebral palsy in Thiruvananthapuram district, Kerala, India. J Neurosci Rural Pract [serial online] 2013 [cited 2017 Nov 21];4, Suppl S1:40-4. Available from: http://www.ruralneuropractice.com/text.asp?2013/4/5/40/116446
| Introduction|| |
Cerebral palsy (CP) refers to a group of permanent disorders of the development of movement and posture, causing activity limitations that are attributed to non progressive disturbances that occurred in the developing fetal or infant brain.  CP has got an estimated prevalence of 2/1000 in the general population.  The motor disorders in CP are often accompanied by disturbances of sensation, perception, cognition, communication, and behavior.  It may often be complicated with epilepsy and secondary musculoskeletal problems.  Impaired control and coordination of voluntary muscles is accompanied by mental retardation or learning disabilities in 50-75% of children and by speech disorders (25%), auditory impairments (25%), seizure disorders (25-35%), or abnormalities of vision (40-50%). 
Physical, social, and environmental factors, service systems and policies existing in the society may influence a person's attitude to his/her impairment or activity limitations.  The physical and social problems imparted by CP start from childhood and extent to the adult life of the patient and several childhood characteristics seem to predict long-term social prognosis.  Youth and adults with this infirmity will require health care support throughout their lives.  So it is important to provide proper training including formal to this most needy segment of population. But their disability complicated by the socio-economic backwardness often prevents them from availing basic human rights including education. Since CP is an evolving disorder in childhood, some limitations may not be evident early in life. But it is usually manifested by the school going age.
Cerebral palsy cannot be cured, but thoughtful interventions including proper education will often improve the child's capabilities.  Besides special education for cerebral palsy patients, a key factor will always be a supportive element. People with a severe degree of cerebral palsy can still be functional and independent. Handicap is the result of limitations imposed by the environment and society, which limits an individual having a specific disability.  Studies also documented the importance and benefits of appropriate education for children with CP. 
There are only few studies which gives an insight into the determinants of formal education among children with CP. This information may be of use, when planning community based strategies for these children. Aim of the study is to find out the proportion of children with cerebral palsy in the age group of 3-12 years who have enrolled for some kind of formal education and to study the determinants of the same among these children.
| Materials and Methods|| |
This hospital based cross sectional study was conducted in the department of physical medicine, medical college hospital, Thiruvananthapuram (Kerala, India). The study participants were children between 3 and 12 years of age diagnosed with cerebral palsy, (diagnosis of CP was made either by a pediatrician or by a neurologist) attending the special clinics conducted at the department of physical medicine and rehabilitation, government medical college, Thiruvananthapuram. Cerebral palsy clinics are routinely conducted at the study setting on 1 st and 3 rd Monday of each month. A team headed by a physician specialized in physical medicine runs the clinic. Physiotherapist, nursing staff and counselors are also part of the team. The main services provided through this clinic are physiotherapy for the children and counseling for the parents. Prosthetic and orthotic appliances are being provided from this clinic with the help of other departments of the medical college or external agencies. About 20-40 children with CP from all over the state attend the clinic on each clinic day. This study was carried out during the last quarter of 2008. No exclusion criteria was fixed, hence all 86 patients who attended the clinic during this period were subjects for the current study.
A semi structured questionnaire was used for the data collection which included variables to assess formal education status of the child, clinical features of the morbidity and socio-economic status of the parents. Primary respondents were parents/guardians who accompanied the children during the hospital visit. Written informed consent was obtained from them before administration of the questionnaire. Those children whose parents/guardians did not give consent were excluded from the study.
Enrollment for any form of formal education was the major outcome variable. The co-variates included educational status of the parents, socio-economic factors, clinical features and clinical history of the disability. The study variables were expressed either in terms of mean (SD) or frequency (%). The factors associated with initiation of formal education were tested using Chi-square test or Fischer's exact test. Independent association of each factor was evaluated through binary logistic regression analysis. A significance level of 95% and a power of 80% were assumed in all these analyses.
| Results|| |
The study population included children between the age of 3 years to 12 years with a mean (SD) age of 5.7 (2.3) years. Forty-six (53.5%) of them were girls. Diplegia was the commonest limb abnormality found (52, 60%) followed by hemiplegia (24, 28.2%), quadriplegia (6, 7.1%) and triplegia (4, 4.7%). Eighty-one children (94.2%) were opting physiotherapy to get relieved from symptoms. Fifty-two (60.5%) children were undergoing some kind of schooling. The mean (SD) at which formal education began was 4.3 (1.4) years. One third of them (27, 31.4%) were using the facilities of Anganwadies (the outreach centers of integrated child development scheme in India, available one per 1000 population) for the initiation of schooling. The educational level of the children is given in [Table 1].
Thirty seven (43.0%) children in the study group were able to walk without the help of other people or without using crutches. Drooling was present in 36 (41.9%), strabismus in 44 (51.2%) and urinary incontinence in 34 (39.5%). Twenty three (23.3%) of them were suffering from any form of mental retardation. The physical and physiological factors associated to the initiation of schooling among children with CP are given in [Table 2].
|Table 2: Physical physiological characteristics and schooling among children with cerebral palsy |
Click here to view
The ability to communicate was assessed in the study population and the following observations were made. Eighty-three (96.5%) of children were able to communicate through vocalization, seventy-two (83.7) of them were able to communicate using words and fifty-five (64.0%) of them were using sentences. The pattern of communication skills of the children associated to schooling is given in [Table 3].
|Table 3: Communicating ability and schooling among children with cerebral palsy |
Click here to view
Regarding the attainment of developmental milestones, 73 (84.9%) achieved head control before two years. Grasp was attained before two years in case of 64 (74.4%) of children. Sixty (69.8%) children were able to transfer objects from one hand to another by the age of 2.5 years. Sit with balance was achieved by 66 (76.7%) children before 2.5 years. These factors were found associated to the initiation of schooling in children with CP, according to the bi-variate analysis [Table 4].
|Table 4: Developmental milestones and schooling among children with cerebral palsy |
Click here to view
The higher mental functions of the children under the study were as follows. 87.2% identified objects correctly and 96.5% identified people correctly. Number concept was present in 43 (50.0%), color concept in 38 (76.0%) and function concept in 58 (67.4%). The relationship of higher mental function of the children under this study and the status of initiation of schooling is given in [Table 5]. Some of the primitive reflexes were persistent in a few children. Sucking reflex and snout reflex were present in 11 (12.8%) children each. Other reflexes maintained were grasp reflex in seven (8.1%), palmomental and glabellar reflexes in four (4.7%) each [Table 6].
|Table 5: Higher mental function and schooling among children with cerebral palsy |
Click here to view
|Table 6: Persistence of primitive reflexes and schooling among children with cerebral palsy |
Click here to view
After bi-variate analysis ability to walk independently, ability of verbal communication, early attainment of almost all developmental milestones and presence of almost all higher mental functions were seen to be significant factors for school enrollment. But factors like presence of drooling, urinary incontinence, mental retardation and persistence primitive reflexes down played school enrollment.
After binary logistic regression three factors, were found to be independently associated with the initiation of formal education in cerebral palsy. Ability of a child to speak in sentences (P = 0.008) and ambulatory level of the child (P = 0.019) were factors which favored enrollment for any form of formal education, but delay in attaining the adaptive developmental milestone of transferring objects from one hand to another (P = 0.014) was found to be detrimental for school enrollment. These three factors could explain more than one third of the variability in the regression model (R2 value of 0.34).
| Discussion|| |
The pattern of most of the clinical and epidemiological features CP recognized by the present study is in concordance with the studies reported from elsewhere. There are reports available in literature which state that diplegia is the commonest limb abnormality in CP as found in the current paper.  Presence of primitive oral reflexes are well documented in CP and one of such studies identified these reflexes among 15 children among a sample size of 60 (25%),  but the proportion of children with primitive reflexes according to the current study is only half of the above mentioned study. Primitive reflexes are more prominent and persist longer in dyskinetic CP.  Majority of children in this study have spastic diplegia (60%), this may be the reason for lower proportion of primitive reflexes when compared to the other study. Physical ability of the children in the current study is in par with that of a reported study from Japan.  Spastic diplegia was the most common type of weakness in CP according to both the papers and more than 40% of the study population could walk without support in both the studies.
A study reported from Shiga, Japan showed that 99% of the children had exposure to schooling,  even though more than two third of the study population is mentally retarded.  But in our setting, less than two third of the children are exposed to some kind of education, even with the proportion of mental retardation (23.3%) is much less than that in Japan. This could be attributed to the social structures and technologies available in a developed country like Japan in comparison to the setting of our study. The social system in resource poor setting is often fail to ensure education to the disadvantaged and marginalized children as that of those suffering from CP. The quality of education delivered to these children was also much different in both the setting. According to the Japanese study 53% of the children entered an elementary school, 41% a special school, and 5% entered a protective institution,  but most of the children in our setting were using the services of Anganwadies. Anganwadies are the outreach centres of integrated child development scheme (ICDS) where an Anganwadi worker is available to give supplementary feeding and pre-school non formal education to the children.  The education related services provided in Anganwadies are non-formal pre-school education to the children from the local community of 3-6 year age group. The worker is not specially trained to deliver education and related services to children who need a special attention. This information is particularly important in the context that, there is evidence that elementary schooling can improve the motor functions and learning skills of a child with CP.  The children in our setting is often denied of such services.
Education is considered one of the most important attribute of one's standard of living and it is an integral component of all indices related to human development. It is absolutely important to provide education to children who are challenged physically and mentally. According to the multivariate model in this study it is evident that the ability to move and communicate is extremely important for a child to start education. It is interesting to see that in the developed world even mental retardation is not a factor which abstain children from achieving minimal educational standards. In our setting only the children who can move and communicate well receive some kind of education and it is also not comparable to the former setting in terms of quality. So we have to focus mainly in two aspects, first is the strategies to improve the motor skills and language skills of the children with CP even from very young age, so that it may enable the child to seek some kind of education. We also have to build a social system that will help these children enable themselves irrespective of their physical disabilities. Both these entities demand special training of care takers in the family, teachers and community workers. Their empowerment will help the children attain. Early improvement in language and motor skills will improve the school going percentage of these differently abled children.
In short, 60.5% children with cerebral palsy in the current study were undergoing formal education and early achievement of physical, cognitive and language milestones was found to be important in determining school enrollment. Persistence of primitive reflexes detains them from the same. Prudent measures should be adopted at family and community levels to aid the development of these children. This helps them to achieve superior educational standards and rehabilitate better and can pave way for a better quality life.
The inclusion of young children (age group of 3-5 years) may be one of the reasons for the perceived lower proportion of schooling. But it should be noted that the network of institutions for informal education (Anganwadi) available in India cater children of 3-6 year age group. In fact the schooling should start early for these children to develop their potentials. The co-morbidities including seizure disorders might have contributed to the failure to schooling which is not included in the analysis.
| References|| |
|1.||Bax M, Goldstein M, Rosenbaum P, Leviton A, Paneth N, Dan B, et al. Proposed definition and classification of cerebral palsy, April 2005. Dev Med Child Neurol 2005;47:571-6. |
|2.||Mayston MJ. Physiotherapy management in cerebral palsy: An update on treatment approaches. In: Scrutton D, Damiano DL, Mayston M, editors. Management of the motor disorders of children with cerebral palsy. 2 nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2004. p. 147-60. |
|3.||Odding E, Roebroeck ME, Stam HJ. The epidemiology of cerebral palsy: Incidence, impairments and risk factors. Disabil Rehabil 2006;28:183-91. |
|4.||Shepherd RB. Cerebral palsy. In: Physiotherapy in paediatrics. 3 rd ed. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann; 1995. p. 110-44. |
|5.||Rosenbaum P, Stewart D. Perspectives on transitions: Rethinking services for children and youth with developmental disabilities. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2007;88:1080-2. |
|6.||Michelsen SI, Uldall P, Kejs AM, Madsen M. Education and employment prospects in cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol 2005;47:511-7. |
|7.||Young NL, Rochon TG, McCormick A, Law M, Wedge JH, Fehlings D. The health and quality of life outcomes among youth and young adults with cerebral palsy. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2010;91:143-8. |
|8.||Stiller C, Marcoux BC, Olson RE. The effect of conductive education, intensive therapy, and special education services on motor skills in children with cerebral palsy. Phys Occup Ther Pediatr 2003;23:31-50. |
|9.||Barbotte E, Guillemin F, Chau N, Lorhandicap Group. Prevalence of impairments, disabilities, handicaps and quality of life in the general population: A review of recent literature. Bull World Health Organ 2001;79:1047-55. |
|10.||Ito J, Araki A, Tanaka H, Tasaki T, Cho K. Intellectual status of children with cerebral palsy after elementary education. Pediatr Rehabil 1997;1:199-206. |
|11.||Anwar S, Chowdhury J, Khatun M, Mollah AH, Begum HA, Rahman Z, et al. Clinical profile and predisposing factors of cerebral palsy. Mymensingh Med J 2006;15:142-5. |
|12.||Love RJ, Hagerman EL, Taimi EG. Speech performance, dysphagia and oral reflexes in cerebral palsy. J Speech Hear Disord 1980;45:59-75. |
|13.||Sankar C, Mundkur N. Cerebral palsy-definition, classification, etiology and early diagnosis. Indian J Pediatr 2005;72:865-8. |
|14.||Suzuki J, Miyajima T, Fujii T. Epidemiological study of cerebral palsy in Shiga prefecture, Japan, during 1977-2000. Part 3: Clinical features of cerebral palsy at six years of age. No To Hattatsu 2009;41:289-93. |
|15.||Suzuki J, Ito M, Tomiwa K, Okuno T. A clinical study of cerebral palsy in Shiga; 1977-1986-III. Diagnosis and treatment of various types of cerebral palsy. No To Hattatsu 1999;31:343-7. |
|16.||Integrated Child Developmental Services (ICDS). Integrated Child Development Scheme. Ministry of Women and Child Development, Government of India. Available from: http://wcd.nic.in/icds.htm [Last accessed on 3 rd Jan 2013]. |
|17.||Schenker R, Coster WJ, Parush S. Neuroimpairments, activity performance, and participation in children with cerebral palsy mainstreamed in elementary schools. Dev Med Child Neurol 2005;47:808-14. |
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5], [Table 6]